Discussion:
PowerDesigner vs Erwin
(too old to reply)
unknown
2007-10-01 18:27:55 UTC
Permalink
Does anyone know of a good objective source where these
tools are compared against each other? Gartner, perhaps?
Paul Horan[TeamSybase]
2007-10-01 19:51:36 UTC
Permalink
Gartner has rated PD #1 in data modeling for several years. We can't
reproduce their results here without getting into copyright infringement
issues...

Here is Sybase's take on the comparison.
http://www.sybase-iad-services.com/powerdesigner/pdf/PD10_vs_Erwin_wp.pdf

Paul Horan[TeamSybase]
Post by unknown
Does anyone know of a good objective source where these
tools are compared against each other? Gartner, perhaps?
Matt Creason
2007-10-02 02:46:00 UTC
Permalink
This is the last Gartner MQ id for PowerDesigner: Data Modeling MQ - "Magic
Quadrant for Database Design Tools", M. Blechar & J. Duggan, M-22-2936, 26
March 2004 . PowerDesigner was and remains the number one position according
to Gartner.

-Matt C.
Post by unknown
Does anyone know of a good objective source where these
tools are compared against each other? Gartner, perhaps?
unknown
2007-10-04 17:23:43 UTC
Permalink
And where would Embarcadero E/R studio fall? Any insight
appreciated.
Post by Matt Creason
This is the last Gartner MQ id for PowerDesigner: Data
Modeling MQ - "Magic Quadrant for Database Design Tools",
M. Blechar & J. Duggan, M-22-2936, 26 March 2004 .
PowerDesigner was and remains the number one position
according to Gartner.
-Matt C.
know of a good objective source where these tools are
compared against each other? Gartner, perhaps?
Matt Creason
2007-11-02 23:51:10 UTC
Permalink
Embarcadero is sittting low #3 or #4 with IBM's recent aquisitions. Last
time I saw any market share numbers they were in the single digits. You can
confirm this with Gartner.

-Matt C.
Post by unknown
And where would Embarcadero E/R studio fall? Any insight
appreciated.
Post by Matt Creason
This is the last Gartner MQ id for PowerDesigner: Data
Modeling MQ - "Magic Quadrant for Database Design Tools",
M. Blechar & J. Duggan, M-22-2936, 26 March 2004 .
PowerDesigner was and remains the number one position
according to Gartner.
-Matt C.
know of a good objective source where these tools are
compared against each other? Gartner, perhaps?
Loading...